« OPEN FORUM: SECURITY BREACH AND TRUE NAMES | Main | UNCANNY VALLEY EXPO: ILIANEXSI SOJOURNER »

Saturday, September 09, 2006

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Crissa

I can't imagine not retaining my purchases when I need to alter them to my own personal use.

I paid for them because I liked them! I kept them because I liked them!

Isn't retaining textures flattery?

Aside from that, isn't it within fair use to personally alter textures you have purchased?

Is it legal to limit this use, or expect it to be limited?

Is it even possible to limit this use? To display an image, it must be decoded, so it must exist on the end users' hardware, whatever that may be. Should artists demand control over that hardware?

Tomas Hausdorff

There has been some significant fall out from the drama aspect of this. Personal attacks have led to the departure of Torrid Midnight from Second Life.

I can't wrap my head around what would drive people to lose themselves so completely in a disagreement over something seemingly so minor that they would hurt each other this way.

I really feel for Torrid, and I think her departure has diminished Second Life.

Amby

This has become so one sided its unbelievable.Have any of you bothered to read the original posts?Both of the original posts ?From beginning to end .If not please do so. Read every post from beginning to end .If you still believe this was some awful way to destroy Torrid ,then Ill understand.

And lets not forget ,Lost also played a role in Relay for Life.He is also a good person,he also has feelings.

Elle Pollack

The drama aside? I recently convinced myself to do pretty much the same thing Torrid did to her skin, which was rip mine, remove the heavy dark eyeliner from the face that had allways bugged me and reupload it. Said skin is never going to leave my posession, even though the creator's name no longer appears in SL's "Find" listing. (I think it fits the spirt if not the leter of the law, as the perms on the skins were copy/*mod*/no transfer). As an artist in training, someday I'll produce a skin of my own that I like and use that instead, but this was more of a quick fix. I don't have a high stakes reputation riding on my SL name, so let the flames fly if it comes to that, but I do continue to sleep at night.

Skins are a tough market. Finding something you like that gets every little detail as you want it without spending huge amounts on a full custom skin is an unlikely possability. Sure the level of quality may be very high, but it can't easily be modified for personal preference; the tone might be off, or it has makeup you don't like or you have a tatoo you want to use. I bought the skin I have because it solves one of those problems; it's a translucent overlay with shading so I can create the skin tone I want and some charactaristic detils like my freckles with the sliders. If LL would go ahead and add some extra texture layers to the AV (a long-desired feature that they've adknowleged but don't seem to have in the current pipeline) a lot of these difficulties would be eased but wishing doesn't make it so nor help the Midnights' predicument. (I would defend their act of editing their skins for the reasons noted above but cannot vouch, good or bad, for anyone's conduct beyond that that brought about the ensuing drama).

farfromfic

I think the three designers in questions learned a very hard and very important lesson here. That being, "Don't F*ck with the FIC". The resulting smear campaign will be vast and brutal.

Aliasi Stonebender

It's a hell of a thing. Indeed, for all intents and purposes making a 'tattoo' undershirt/pants does exactly the same thing, thanks to SL's texture-baking. There is no discernable difference in the end product. The head is the exception because there are no clothing items to cover the head, and this is a silly UI limitation, not a technical one.

So... while I'll refrain from commenting on the specifics of this case, given it's very he said/she said at this point, I fail to see the problem with 'ethical' texture-ripping (buy the skin, rip it, make whatever modifications you need, reupload and do not distribute) as this is the sort of thing that is entirely within fair use in most other situations.

icon

Trusting Secondlife

I created a spin-off post hoping to enlighten us all around the issues of fair use. I hope it will lead to a further post where I might interview a lawyer or law student on the subject of fair use and derivative works. Maybe we can get some real insight into the issue at the core of this problem.

As for how I feel about what's happened...

Torrid isn't some drama queen looking for attention with this post. Whoever caused this situation seems unbelievably inconsiderate and immature. Perhaps they just have a tenuous grasp of reality -- whatever the case, they've caused undue harm.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Your Information

(Name is required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)

Wagner James Au VR virtual worlds
Free virtual world for web PC & Mac from OpenSim Pioneers
Ample Avi
SL Yacht
my site ... ... ...