« I Talk Google Profiles, Pseudonyms & Second Life on the BBC | Main | Beth Odets, Longtime SL Community Leader & Artist, Needs Brain Surgery IRL - Famed SL Designer Eshi Otawara Selling Her Fashion 50% Off to Help Cover Costs »

Wednesday, August 03, 2011

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Maxwell Graf

This is vaporware BS technology, and has been popping up for several years now and again. check reddit or http://notch.tumblr.com/

Adeon Writer

Notch of Minecraft fame is saying this is a scam: http://notch.tumblr.com/

Adeon Writer

Ninja'd!

Hamlet Au

Haha, so John Carmack, the king of high end 3D graphics, thinks it's possible, but Notch, the king of blocky 16 bit graphics, thinks it's not?

Ananda

I see no reason why we couldn't have both be true... that the base technology here might prove useful in future graphics but that this particular implementation is a scam.

Hamlet Au

Well I asked Carmack, if we're lucky he'll reply.

bongo

Voxels and point clouds.. both a decade plus old. Pretty Demo, but thats what it was.

Tateru Nino

I have to go with Notch on this one. There's nothing new here that we haven't seen before.

Nexii Malthus

Doesn't help that their website looks like a chinese scam site, see http://unlimiteddetailtechnology.com/

Ehrman Digfoot

Well I don't think we need to bother Carmack again. Notch's post is pretty clear itself if you read it, and Ananda summarizes his argument well. This implementation is a scam, not the future of voxel technology itself. Notch concludes his post making the same point as Carmack.

Myf McMahon

Carmack thinks it's real? Are you basing your conclusion on that one rather vague Tweet of his? The one observing that you're not going to see games on current gen systems? That's a pretty extraordinary conclusion Hamlet.

I suggest you read Notch's blog posting, he actually backs up his conclusion with a few facts and figures. Dismissing someone out of hand, based on a half baked (and no doubt uniformed) opinion of their depth of knowledge, is pretty foolish.

Hamlet Au

That's why I double-checked with Carmack. :)

Cube Republic

Oh this BS again (5 years after seeing it the first time)

Ann Otoole InSL

I second Cube's remark. In addition this stuff stinks of venture capital raising scamminess. Did they ever find 5 bucks for a godaddy website?

I expect to see vastly improved everything in 10 years. The entire paradigm is likely to change by then. Unless the governments of the world close the internet down.

qarl

my take:

they're using sparse voxels with instancing. it's not revolutionary. it's not even really clever. it has serious drawbacks, which they somehow forgot to mention.

there are MANY people exploring voxel trees these days. google for "sparse voxel rendering." my favorite is this guy:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_CCZIBDt1uM

Daniel

Did anyone actually bother to read the first 1 or 2 sentences of the engine's concept? This has nothing at all to do with voxels. It may remind of the concept, but this kind of point cloud renderer has much more in common with raytracing implicit surfaces than it does with voxels.

Daniel

To be fair, and to proactively exculpate myself if *I* got it wrong: the company's own descriptions of their concept make it sometimes very hard to understand what they actually claim to be doing. They should get someone with language skills on that.

red bottom

I'd be interested in hearing. The TOS seems rather clear that it is not unless expressly approved by Amazon. I guess if the library got it in writing then they would be ok.

stinky472

As Carmack said, he doesn't disagree with anything Notch said. The company is very disingenuous about discussing the limitations of a voxel renderer like the inability to do animations effectively.

Voxel engines do have potential for the static aspects of the world. That's what Carmack is talking about when it comes to blending polygon-based technologies with voxel ones.

Notch is right. People just don't seem to like his level of directness.

Mitur Binesderti

When Notch can build a 3D engine that uses basic object occlusion I'll start listening to him. Until then he's just a really smart guy that wrote a horrible 3D engine and who doesn't understand basic 3D engine design.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Your Information

(Name is required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)

Wagner James Au VR virtual worlds
Free virtual world for web PC & Mac from OpenSim Pioneers
Ample Avi
SL Yacht
my site ... ... ...