Tuesday, July 30, 2013

« NWN Survey: Should Educators & Non-Profits Get a Second Life Sim Under the Restored 50% Discount Plan? | Main | Best Mod Yet? Skyrim Savegame Manager Makes Juggling Multiple Adventurers Easier Than Ever »

Chinese MMO Age of Wushu's New Castration Mechanic Might Be Going Too Far In The Name of History

Age of Wushu 1
Janine "Iris Ophelia" Hawkins' ongoing review of gaming and virtual world style

Age of Wushu, an MMORPG inspired by Chinese fantasy, is adding a controversial new feature to their world of colorfully dressed, gravity defying warrior-calligraphers: Castration. Yes, you read that right. An MMO where male player characters can be forcibly castrated by enemy players.

This is definitely not something you're going to see in the WoW patch notes.

While I might know where I stand on the issue players of enslaving NPCs in a game, I'm not at all sure where I am on this. (Trigger warning; proceed with caution)

Age of Wushu 2First I want to give you some background on this game because it's not a run-of-the-mill MMO, and understanding that is key. Age of Wushu is a rather weird game, and in spite of the colorful fantasy setting it takes its world rather seriously. When you log out, your character does not simply cease to be. You are offered a few different jobs you can choose from, based mostly on your character's level in society, and once you leave your character will become an NPC filling that role. Acrobat, traveler, merchant, noble, there are quite a few roles to choose from. While this is an interesting way of making a player feel like they actually have a tangible place in the game's world, it's not all sunshine and roses. Other players can kidnap offline players who are doing their various scripted NPC tasks using "knockout powder", carrying them in a sack to a broker who will then buy the kidnapped player for a hefty sum (unless another player manages to rescue the "merchandise" along the way). This is an element of the game that bothered me when I tried the game a few months ago, but is couched in a lot of vagueness, has negligible consequences (a debuff), and is buried in a sea of fetch quests and grinding.

This game has a very strong historical and cultural component, moreso than any other games I've played in similar settings. Crafting abilities like calligraphy are just as important as being able to make gear, and poetry metagames are part of how the developers engage with the community.

Age of Wushu feels very carefully put together. There is an obvious interest in being faithful to both the beautiful and ugly sides of reality in some regard even within the fantasy (and I appreciate that this isn't used as an excuse to make female characters take a back seat). I guess when I call it weird, what I really mean is that it's interesting... In a very weird and sometimes uncomfortable way. Given all this, the presence of kidnapping mechanics and castration makes sense. Both kidnapping and forced castration existed in ancient China, so they both have a place in this story.


To be clear, the castration process in Age of Wushu is also fairly complicated. There's only a chance of success, and if the action fails the player sustains significant damage, according to this interview with the developers. NPCs will try to help the player, but most NPCs won't stand much of a chance against the 5 other players required to form the group to carry this out. It will also only work against players who are at a certain level, so at least it won't be a way for assholes to harass and humiliate new players.

If they complete the castration process, the victim receives an invitation to join their clan, the Rootless, but other than that it seems to change very little about actually playing the game.

Even so, part of me is horrified at the idea. It's true you're not losing anything that's measured in stats or meters or inventory slots, but it feels much more significant. It's something being taken from you on a more personal level, and it can't be returned, repaired, or regained. Loss penalties in games, especially MMOs, are rarely (if ever) permanent in the same way. Even though it never really existed in the first place, it matters.

I really don't want to invoke the R-word here (I try to always think twice before I do, especially when it comes to gaming) but if it was a group of five players carrying a female character off into that tent that's exactly what it would be, and sadly that also has a place in history. That's a line I doubt the developers of Age of Wushu (or of most games) would be willing to cross quite so explicitly (even though they aren't staying entirely clear of it either, in the case of quest NPCs who have been sold to brothels directly) but it doesn't make me feel much better, especially given the fact that we don't really know how this will be treated. The kidnapping never quite felt like it had the appropriate weight -- it was almost caperish and gimmicky, even when selling someone to a "darkminded trafficker" (Edit: Which in many ways implies rape, even if the game refuses to say so outright). As awful as selling someone, the game handles it with vagueness, distance, and negligible in-game consequences. Kidnapping is ultimately a minor irritation because of this, and maybe it says something that the new feature stands out to me far more than the other admittedly unsettling content did when I was playing Age of Wushu. The vagueness doesn't excuse it, but it makes the explicitness of the castration feature seem much more jarring.

I'm not male and I rarely play males, but I have enough empathy to find something about this genuinely upsetting, even if it really does fit within the world. It might just be one step too far.

Please share this post with people you like:

Mixed reality iris 2013Iris Ophelia (@bleatingheart, Janine Hawkins IRL) has been featured in the New York Times and has spoken about SL-based design at the Fashion Institute of Technology in Manhattan and with pop culture/fashion maven Johanna Blakley.


TrackBack URL for this entry:

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Chinese MMO Age of Wushu's New Castration Mechanic Might Be Going Too Far In The Name of History:


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.


Oh man :s... "The Talk" is gonna have a good laugh over this!

Emperor Norton

So what level is your Age of Wushu character Janine?

Adeon Writer

I think I'll pass on Age of Wushu, or any other game from a developer who seems a little too obsessed with my wushu.

Wolf Baginski

I know enough history that I would accept "Eunuch" as a character-design option. Eunuchs were often the administrative staff of a government. They could be powerful characters. Maybe they're best reserved for NPCs, the patron who sends the adventurers on a mission.

Making it something that groups of players can force on other characters is bad. Sure, they can kill you, but this feels wildly different. I can't articulate why the difference, but there is one.

Adeon Writer

Wolf, I can easily tell you why it's different.

When you are killed, you respawn. You were dead, but now you aren't. You "got better."

However I'm guessing what is done to the player here will not be fixed by getting yourself killed. As such it's a condition worse than death.

Sarah Thompson

What a ridiculous nonevent to be getting bent out of shape about.

For one you can straight up grow back your junk if you don't join or leave the rootless clan. Yup you can go rootless multiple times if you want the game doesn't care. Second the rootless clan are incredibly powerful with the right skill sets. Thirdly a similar option is necessary for female characters as well to use the sunflower manual who can also regrow some ovaries if they don't want to do it anymore.

Post a comment

If you have a TypeKey or TypePad account, please Sign In.