« Open Source VR Mixed Reality Project Combines Arduino, Robots, and Unity to Produce Real Life Sounds When Touching Virtual Objects | Main | New World Notes' Weekend Open Forum: Say Anything About VR & VWs »

Thursday, December 14, 2017

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Clara Seller

Smacking Strawberry Singh is great PR. They have some pretty sharp tacks there at LL.

They should make an example of her. Drone attacks or maybe some directed energy weapons to her compound.

Corporate property is sacred. She must be stopped.

Nalates Urriah

Unfortunately, this will likely be one of those things that do not show up in the Linden accounting stats. So, the Lab will have no idea how much damage this stance has/will cause.

Tweet @ebbealtberg w/ #berryCopyright and ask what's up? Maybe include a question about whether he has any idea how much free publicity LL is going to lose.

Willow Dion

This may be the straw that broke the camel’s back for me. I have been watching LL’s stupidity for twelve years and they go from one disaster to another. Never missing a chance to make a stupid move to denigrate the people who keep them financially alive.

Currently for personal reasons I am on “vacation” from SL and only logging in about once a month. Now I’m thinking I should make that “vacation” permanent!

NorthernKiara

I think this is all because Strawberry makes income from the videos maybe.

VirtuallySheree

I'm just glad that of all the destinations I write about, that not once did I even bother try to encourage others to join Second Life with some easy to understand information on how to get started. It's not as if traffic has been falling in Second Life. Oh wait.

Alicia Chenaux

I was lucky enough not to get hit with a trademark complaint. However, as a precaution, I also removed 2 tutorial videos. One was on how to sell your $Lindens, and one was on how to sell on the marketplace. The marketplace one was my highest viewed video, and also the one with the most comments because I explained everything in an easy manner.

The learning curve in Second Life is incredibly steep. Tutorials are not easy to find. You're more likely to find videos of trolls screaming and making SL look like a cesspool rather than the wonderful world it can be. When vloggers make good, decent, easy to understand tutorials, that helps people to come to this world and STAY in this world. I have a feeling Linden Lab does not understand how many new residents have joined because they saw videos on YouTube that were more than trolling.

I also cannot understand why Linden Lab would not want work with someone like Strawberry, who has an incredible amount of viewers, to allow her to use the logo and show the website so that people learn how to make an avatar. Isn't she giving them free publicity? Or do they intend on making their own video on how to become a Second Life resident, and they don't want the competition?

UnMonetize

Do_not_monetize the videos that feature the offending SL content for which Strawberry got hit with. THAT is why they are filing the complaints. You cannot make money on someone's trademark. If you leave them unmonetized they won't do anything.

Lusus

Linden Labs are clearly being over protective of their eye in hand logo, particularly as other online platforms such as Facebook, Google+, Twitter etc don't actively prevent people using their logos on their websites etc. In fact its good business practise when these logos are used to link back to their content.

In fact many designers have created their own versions of these logos to fit in with the look of various websites. It would hurt no one if Linden Labs loosened up a bit and allowed people more scope.

Dazza Vlogs

Unfortunately, I was one of the few to be hit with this Trademark complaint. I felt like I was doing something good by helping new people get involved with Second Life. The tutorials would have been nearly impossible to create without showing off the website a little. Seeing as I am only 18, it is quite scary to receive any kind of legal complaint.

This has generally put me off the whole Second Life platform. I am considering not posting anymore YouTube content about Second Life what so ever because I want to feel free to post my own original content without worrying about any legal obligations.

I do not want to post YouTube content anymore because I feel worried that this will happen again and again. This may generally be the end of my love for Second Life. These videos started off as a hobby to entertain people and give information about in-world items and I never dreamt of there being something "legal" behind it.

This is very sad and generally shocking. I never thought that Linden Labs would do this when all we are doing is advertising for them free of charge.

joanie34

LL's Trademark Guidelines:

'License for Press Use of the Second Life Eye-in-Hand Logo. We’ve given journalists and media outlets special permission to use the Second Life Eye-in-Hand Logo in published articles, blog entries, and news programs specifically about the Second Life virtual world, subject to our Guidelines and Terms and Conditions'

Tia Linden's email to Strawberry:

'More specifically, we do not allow images of our avatar building page, home pages or Second Life Eye In Hand Logo to be used in any capacity. Please do not use images of any Second Life web pages or logos ( with the exception of our inSL logo noted at https://secondlife.com/corporate/brand/insl/#) in your video or any other work. You may provide a link to our website or registration page in your video if you wish.'

Don't these two statements directly contradict each other??


Dartagan Shepherd

Wait, Second Life is still around? Heheh.

moses

haw haw

Drew956

Linden Labs can sod off. (I'm using "sod off" because it doesn't feel like a cussword to me, since I'm American. Hopefully this is okay)
Trashiest producers of anything ever, zero appreciation for the potential Second Life has as a platform or for their users.
They are the WORST possible owners/producers of something like Second Life.
Corporate Greed and lack of caring about or fostering the community makes me detest LL.
If I ever, EVER, create something like SL Linden Labs will be the prime example of how to NOT manage it. Period.
I am severely disappointed in them. What a sucky company.

Brooke Barmy

It seems Linden Lab chooses to focus on their own IP rights instead of creator rights. Regarding Strawberry Singh specifically, the amount of positive and free publicity that she gives Second Life when their marketing avenues are laughable is truly astonishing.

Han Held

Let's say, for the sake of argument, that the monetization argument holds water (it doesn't, but let's pretend it does).

Over the years, Strawberry has given them material for their website, created and contributed windlight settings, promoted the use of mesh body parts (and made them more accessible), and helped new (and in my case, old) users make sense of Secondlife.

If she's made pennies from this, Linden Lab has made dollars from the people who have used her content and then bought the items she's promoted and and then made dollars again as those people rented server space ("land") to create places to show off their purchases.

Yeah, maybe it is about money. From where I sit, it's about LL throwing away dollars to grab at a few pennies, and that makes no sense at all.

It's still short-sighted and moronic.

Ivey Deschanel

Great work! ffs...they should be collaborating with Berry to make an officially sponsored introductory video to SL. Instead, they do this kind of reactionary and unnecessary BS to people that ENCOURAGE & EDUCATE NEW PLAYERS. Congrats LL you have just discouraged anyone from promoting your product on youtube or on their blogs. GAH

Oobleck

If only they were as attentive to content creator's items being infringed upon.

Han Held

They turned around (inside of two days!), copped to their mistake, reversed course and apologized. It's still a dumb mistake that should never have happened, but it's a good sign that they both copped to it and took action to fix it.

I have to admit I was pleasantly surprised.

sirhc deSantis

Shock horror Lab actually realises they put foot in mouth...and react to it. Well done.
Funny really. Memory not being what it was but a quick check throws up a slew of stories about a certain account being compromised last year with a very similar (as in exactly the same) Linden name.

irihapeti

thank goodness it got reversed.

for sure can say Nobody Is Above The Law.

except when add ...the law of a moderator who has no idea about who or what they are moderating, or even why they are

is quite woeful the actual inworld experience and knowledge of the SL community, of some LL moderators

Bixyl Shuftan

I waited until Linden Lab responded before making a comment. While it's good that they apologized, why did they hassle Strawberry to begin with? While we of course thank Linden Lab for creating Second Life in the first place, and they've done some good moves since, it seems they have a way of making a blunder just as we're starting to think they have their act together.

Clara Seller

I hope this wakes LL up, just a little, that they have customers and a job to do.

This incident could have been a bigger financial blow than that albatross, Sansar.

For years, LL has been all too happy to cut backroom deals and play favorites with their star-maker machinery if they can make a dollar along the way. How this affected the common society and it's future... it's just Capitalism, babe.

They were lucky, this time, it was Strawberry Singh. She's kind.

But it was really nice to watch them squirm.

Phoenix Desmoulins

I'm confused. Why is showing how to join at all protected? "SL join flow" is not a secret, it's not revolutionary, and it's certainly not worth alienating your contributors over..

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Your Information

(Name is required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)

Wagner James Au VR MMO blog New World Notes
Sinespace Unity MMO
Ample Avi  SL avatars
SL fashion blog Cajsa Gidge
my site ... ... ...