« How To Get Free Expo Passes To Virtual Worlds London | Main | Other World Notes: Xbox Obama, Wii Speak, Warhammer »

Monday, October 13, 2008

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Doubledown Tandino

Morris is a genius! and he's got smarts too!

Ann Otoole

Nice assessment. Keep in mind that the hardware needed to run SL well is a year old or less today. This technology will become cheaper quickly so in another year, when the wal mart consumers have access to decent stuff, then the number of people that can participate enjoyably will increase.

The barrier Windlight introduced was mandatory nVidia 8000 GPU, 4GB RAM, and a 64 bit OS or better. Many of us continue to think there needs to be a LL maintained low end browser that contains no Windlight functionality at all. Especially if the Lab wants to push SL as an educational medium given the general capability of school computers.

Morris Vig

Interesting thoughts, Hamlet. Can't say as I disagree.

The key is not the technology, though. It's the social engagement that comes from the technology. SL is one heck of a platform, but it's the connections that it makes that keeps us coming back.

VIajero

"The barrier Windlight introduced was mandatory nVidia 8000 GPU, 4GB RAM, and a 64 bit OS or better."

Bull. If one did any research at all, they'd find that PLENTY of people on SL, utilizing Windlight, with far lower specs. That's what I've found.

Includng me: nVidia 6200, 1GB RAM, and 32 bit Windows. FPS aren't pretty, but usually workable, and I hardly ever crash.

I'm all for Linden focusing on stability and lowering the technology barrier to SL, but exaggeration doesn't help this cause.

Martien Pontecorvo

I think one of the problems that SL faces is that *everything* is locked up tight on Linden Lab's servers, and every time you log in, you have to wait for *everything* to download. That's textures, prims, animations, sounds, even the UI graphics and sound effects.

People signing up for the first time need to be grabbed ASAP, but that's not likely to happen if they end up flailing around in a grey void. Unfortunately, as long as the bandwidth is clogged with not only movement updates, but also world information, people are going to be put off by the tardy response of the system.

I think more trust needs to be given to the client side. E.g. the servers would still serve a role, storing persistent builds, handling Lindex transactions, and other functions best suited to centralised systems, but also instructing clients to send data about their inventory to other clients -- a sort of peer-to-peer asset system running alongside the central grid, taking some of the load off.

However, given the state of some broadband connections, this might not be a good idea, although being able to backup your inventory to local disk seems to be a much-desired feature.

SL lag comes from too much data being transferred, and until the packets get fewer, richer and smaller, we'll just have to put up with it.

Iggy Os

I got a bit of a drubbing from fellow educators when I suggested that these tech barriers hurt adoption of SL by "mainstream" faculty in higher ed.

Give a time-strapped, constantly assessed faculty member this reality and they won't bother to see the treasures that SL offers.

And while students will dutifully complete a project in SL, I don't think they'll be sticking around or coming on their own--especially on their laptops. Thus we see LL's percentage of residents 18-25 decline, as cited elsewhere in NWN.

rightasrain

sorry Morris, not sure I buy that although concept that a hardcore user is online more of course makes sense. But by definition, hardcore users are a small percentage.

It is of course perplexing...but Linden Lab of course has all the answers to the real user activity in SL--maybe one day they will share it.

Their view of "community" is more like the hardcore users are guinea pigs stress testing their platform--and paying to do it.

Major unknowns in the user activity--

* Bots--someone at LL said this was like 20% of concurrency, but how much of monthly hours?

* how many sessions for newbies never leave orientation or get passed first 1 hour inworld?

* how many people are all these avatars?

* how much traffic is on private islands? or at least sections of the grid that are not viewable in search. So this would take out IBM closed sims for example.

* How much traffic is from LL staff? (Although they never seem to be inworld)but they should report their hours or net them off.

Lish Lach

If you want to see what "concurency" is all about these days, search for vertical avatar stacks on your Map, teleport over, and try to strike up a conversation with the crowd. More often than not, you won't get a single response, because they're all bots. (If you'd like to see a 24/7 example, try Orient 80, 150, 50.)

What's puzzles me is why the puppeteers often take the time to "personalize" each bot with faux SL and RL bios in their profiles. Who are they trying to fool with these charades?

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Your Information

(Name is required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)

Wagner James Au VR MMO blog New World Notes
Sinespace Unity MMO
Ample Avi  SL avatars
Tableau_SL_Nylon_pinkney
Click to visit Nylon Pinkey's many fashion brands in Second Life: Nylon Outfitters, Golden Years, Wrigglesworth Residence, Yummy, and Art Nails
my site ... ... ...