« Hottest Male Avatars of 2009: 30 Semifinalists Selected! | Main | New World Newsfeed: Linden Lab's Former CFO Jumps to Blue Mars »

Tuesday, December 15, 2009

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Crap Mariner

Texture: Rick Astley's face
Sound: chorus from "Never Gonna Give You Up"
Animation: Rick's dance from the video

-ls/cm

Lizzie Lexington

Hahahaha, I love the kitty! That's a super idea!

Thorn Witrial

I can see this as a new griefing tool for someone to file a false claim with LL and get a competitor, or just someone they don't like, in serious trouble. If Linden Labs doesn't do a rigorous front end look at the complaint, and just does the switch without checking first, it could seriously hurt someone's reputation to have their shops suddenly filled with this new IP Content Theft mark of shame.

If LL does take care to not inflict this on people who are innocent of wrong doing, it has the potential to be a great warning to avoid the dishonest. If they do not take care and fire it blindly wherever they are aimed, it's going to bring the grid to a new low.

Doreen Garrigus

Thorn has a point. This could definitely be used as a griefing tool.

LL isn't required to check to make sure the allegations are accurate. They do not verify the legitimate owner of the copyright.

The DMCA only requires that they take content down when someone alleges it is infringing. If the party who has their material taken down files a counter notice, LL has to put it back up. No verification is required. No conflict is resolved. Linden Lab is done with their part.

I hope that the Lab has some process in place to identify people who are abusing the DMCA, but I have not seen any evidence that they do.

Metacam Oh

So now when people falsely claim infringement, everyone will now be able to see it and believe it?

Doreen Garrigus

That's the gist of it, Metacam.

Resident Pixel

sadly - i don't think LL has much leeway in how they respond to a DCMA complaint - the law is written to heavily favor griefing like this.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Digital_Millennium_Copyright_Act#Criticisms

Myf McMahon

Exactly. The DMCA requires a first response of takedown. Regardless of follow up investigations, the initial response is to treat the claim as genuine.

Without a punitive response to frivolous claims, this will result in some pretty nasty messes. Even with punishment, it will be used to grief.

AnnOtooleInSL

Generally griefers have avoided actually violating the law in ways that could result in them being imprisoned and made the cell block "toy". What makes you think they are going to suddenly begin risking becoming a cell block sex slave over a video game?

Sure the possibility exists but it is never going to be worth risking your freedom over some SL content. Hopefully some low level sanity reflex will stop people from committing suicide by convict justice.

Doreen Garrigus

False DMCA claimsare pretty common everywhere.

Connie Sec

I predict a spike in Tit for Tat.

Talwyn Mills

While the fast-track DCMA might be a good idea, but it apears the only way of getting the content back against an incorrectly and/or maliciously DMCA notice is to follow the old DMCA rules.

10 seconds to take down, days/months/who-knows-how-long to get back?

If a maliciously filed DMCA takes out a large portion of a merchants products, that merchant could loose quite a lot of income while things are being sorted out but they still have to pay for (for example) land they were using as a store.

Plus DMCA's are a great way of getting peoples personal information, I don't know if the receiver of the DMCA gets the accusers info, but if you want to file a counter-claim, the claiment gets your RL details.

Arcadia Codesmith

To answer the original question... while the kitty is appreciated, it might be best in this instance to stick with something fairly stuffy and conventional like, "Content Under Dispute" - maybe with fine print to make it clear that while LL is compelled to take action on the basis of a DMCA notice or face liability, taking such action in no way represents a judgement that infringement has taken place.

DMCA needs an overhaul. It's a Mickey Mouse law drafted in corporate boardrooms, intended to legitimize intimidation tactics against non-infringing fair use, and to undermine the very concept of the public domain. It's ill-suited for the online environment, where corporations are a dying remnant of the last century and any user can be a producer.

Arcadian Vanalten

Well, and worse, the DMCA was written mostly by people who had very little understanding of the nature of digital media as a whole. It was, as I recall, never intended to be more than a temporary stopgap until a better law could be developed, but then they never really revisited it. Granted, I'm not a lawyer and my recollection of this could be flawed.

I agree that it would be a lot wiser to replace it w/ a notification that indicated unresolved dispute rather than implying presumed guilt. A reputable designer could find him/herself destroyed in the court of public opinion with a store loaded with notices falsly depicting them as content thieves. Not that the SL fashion scene has anyone drama-inclined or vindictive enough to consider doing that to someone, right? *smirks ironically*

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Your Information

(Name is required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)

Wagner James Au
Really Needy HUD for Second Life roleplay
Dutchie SL waterfront cottages
Sinespace virtual world Unity free home
Samsung Edge computing reports NWN
my site ... ... ...