« Face the Faces of New World Notes' Facebook Fans | Main | Georgia Tech Study Paying $100 in Linden Dollars for Avatar/RL Behavioral Research on Active Second Life Users »

Monday, August 09, 2010

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

comoro Infinity

what a gigantic waste of time

Fogwoman Gray

Chicken cannons...
BUH BAWK!!

Bob L

Like The Matrix movies failure of imagination. The characters are in a world were they can dress how ever they want so they chose the same clothes as everyone else?

Ghosty Kips

I have not yet seen the movie, so I have only two comments.

1. That is the funniest image I have seen all week. WIN.

2. People who feel the Matrix was a failure of imagination never took a philosophy class in their entire life.

I can only hope for vampiric robo-tiger lesbian steampunk penises.

Sinnyo

In defence of the film, which did still show dreams playing merry havoc with mirrors, folded-in cities and a lack of gravity, I can't say I've ever had a dream in which batallions of Ruth-bots have showered me in miniature airships. I was quite prepared to accept DiCaprio's line, that the subconscious seeks always of make sense of things. It's usually the *circumstances* which feel weird in a dream, such as launching ski-mounted attacks upon Russian fortresses or being inexplicably lost among a city of grey block skyscrapers. It's *imagination* which conjures pig cannons, and that takes a certain degree of conscious thought.

I thought the film much more game-related anyway. It's a group of people creating worlds in which the protagonist is gently led to a conclusion of their device, all by suggestion as subtle as an FPS' street map or the laying of clues about a platformer. Nothing about "Inception" seems to suggest a free-reign world like "Second Life".

Annyka Bekkers

My dreams only seem strange after I wake up. They make perfect sense while I'm experiencing them

Leondra

I will most definitely have to see, after all the revisiting in your mind, through posts. It is a test of a really good movie (or book, poem, work of art, etc), to keep re-thinking scenes and meanings, looking at various levels.

LokiLoki

Ive not seen Wagner comment on Sy Fy's Caprica series yet and how THAT is like Second Life right down to the virtual sex, violence and bots.

brinda allen

OMG! The look on the face of the last image is exactly what I would expect to see after the exchange about steampunk dirigibles...vampire lesbians evading robot furry tigers shooting 2.424242xxxxx meter male sex organs! ROFL!

Vaneeesa Blaylock

For me, The Matrix (the first one) is one of the greatest films. Lots of sexy action, AND, a ton of powerful ideas.

Inception was visual spectacle but I didn't find it to have nearly the ideas that The Matrix did.

Still, compared to the mess that was Salt, Inception was a masterpiece.

So far for me, the most "real" film this summer - not because it's marginally related to some "real" event, but because of the characters possessing actual human emotions, is Middle Men.

Adric Antfarm

Didn't see enough of this on Reddit did we?

Oz Spade

The reason the dreams aren't crazy is because they don't want the mark to know he/she is dreaming. The only time I can really see the "it wasn't crazy enough" argument working is when they fall into the subconscious, which I imagine could have been more fanciful. However when you consider the purpose to which the subconscious was being used it makes a certain sense. Also I think Nolan was trying to make a specific kind of movie and having a green troll running around shooting flamingos out of a pie that must be reloaded by radio stations, while perfectly dream-like, doesn't really fit in with a dramatic action heist flick.

Hamlet Au

I agree with you, Oz, I just thought they could have added a few more dream-like elements. For example, why do Fischer's subconscious defense projections look like everyday action movie mercenaries susceptible to bullets, rather than weird indestructible demonic things or whatever the fuck?

Brinda, that Leo DiCaprio squint makes me giggle every time. I might just make *all* my posts include it!

Rodion Resistance

Forgive me for this rant but why is there such a seeming need for this certain "haughtiness" when it comes to describing that Inception doesn't come close to Second Life? (i.e. "Ugh, these people don't know what 'dreamlike means', I should know because I've been in SL").

I mean seriously, over half the people I know who watched it (and who aren't into SL) didn't like it because they had difficulty in following the plot as it is. And how do you suppose, it would help them if there were "hand cannons with exploding pigs" all mixed into the fray? To me therefore, this need for something to be as wildly flamboyant as "vampire lesbians evading robot furry tigers shooting male sex organs" in order to be "more dreamlike" and "more like SL" is no different from that yearning of some that to be "cool" in a dream scene you have to be wearing black trenchcoats and dark glasses with black slick hairdos.

The movie was "dumbed down" so that the rest of humanity (who do not use SL) can actually still understand it and appreciate it as a movie that has "dreamlike" scenes but does not stray from the obvious fact that, for a movie to be enjoyable (and profitable) it still does have to make sense.

L. Knoller


"can you say Brrhh?"

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZrYPJ4Yc31g

Nat Merit

There is absolutely no plot hole at all around the dream worlds being mostly 'mundane' and realistic.

The architect's job is the keep the world acting like a consistent real world place (where fantastical elements like loops and limitations are hidden) so the dreamer doesn't realise they're dreaming.

The whole premise is based around a misuse of army training tech that uses dreams to produce realistic shared scenarios. Penis torpedo would make no sense within the story's carefully established context.

WakingLife

Comparing Matrix and Inception, it is clear that Matrix is by far the less sophisticated one regarding the underlying idea.
Where Matrix questions the nature of our perception of reality, it does so in an easy, straightforward manner: We are never confused as to what is "real" and what is the "dreamworld". Inception poses the same question of "Life As Illusion", but goes one step further. Many things in the movie deliberately contradict the diegetic reality, (like the scene where Cobb is chased, and the walls close in)giving far more food for thought about what is the dream, but also about the relationship between the experience of watching a movie, and the experience of dreaming, and by implication the relationship between filmmaker and audience.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Your Information

(Name is required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)

Wagner James Au VR MMO blog New World Notes
Sinespace Unity MMO
Ample Avi  SL avatars
Tableau_SL_Nylon_pinkney
Click to visit Nylon Pinkey's many fashion brands in Second Life: Nylon Outfitters, Golden Years, Wrigglesworth Residence, Yummy, and Art Nails
my site ... ... ...