« Woman Who Criticizes Violence Against Women in Games Now in Hiding Due to Real Death Threats from Gamers | Main | I Love Games, But I'll Never Be a "Gamer" »

Wednesday, August 27, 2014


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.


DMCA is complicated and I don't have a better solution.

But much of the Marketplace content theft problem is due to the utter trifling laziness of LL to earn their paycheck off of that place. Selling on Marketplace should be a privilege that comes with some responsibility. Nobody should be selling on that place without some solid RL verification.

Then the lab should permanently ban anyone who is caught doing the copy/paste ad trickery that is mucking up Marketplace. Most of this is so blatant that it shouldn't require a DMCA. It just requires someone who halfway cares to manage the place.

There needs to be a way to flag stolen content on Marketplace without having to buy it and review it.


I have said this many, many times, but I'll say it here again, regarding that first comment: I was not Curio's only lawyer. I'm not a litigator (in other words, I'm not the kind of lawyer that goes to court), and as most people remember, Gala was dealing with an actual lawsuit.

COPYRIGHT LAWSUITS ARE EXPENSIVE. Lawsuits in general are extremely hard on those involved. And settlements are often under mutual gag orders.

Continuing to insinuate that Gala was off sipping mai tais during that time is just willful ignorance.


I promised Iris I'd comment again on the whole piece after I'd slept.

A lot of the responses seem to be focused on the frustration around the inability to get a malicious copier to take a copied item down and keep it down, and the desire for some sort of "takedown means staydown" process.

Google that phrase: "takedown means staydown." You'll quickly see that it's RIAA and the MPAA's new rallying cry, and is the cornerstone behind the rebranding of SOPA. And that's fair, because let's be honest: content creators, whether they're texture designers working for micropayments in Second Life or Michael Bay working for tens of millions of dollars in Hollywood, get really damn tired of playing whack-a-mole with every yahoo who wants to throw ripped copies up for free, and every time content creators issue a takedown notice, the bad guys just pop back up again somewhere else with the same ripped content, so the whack-a-mole game starts up again.

And the lobbying to Congress gets louder, and the copyright penalties get stricter, and the copyright laws get more draconian (again, SOPA / PIPA was a law aimed at copyright infringers), and the international trade treaties get tighter and tighter copyright restrictions built into them, and it becomes harder and harder for individuals and small businesses to protect themselves in court on copyright matters...

...and the group damaged the most is the public — all of us, everyone — because the more we fight to bend the law to fix one specific problem, the more we unsettle the careful balances the law has built into it.

Here's why.

Let's say, hypothetically, that we were able to build a "takedown means staydown" system into the DMCA. This could mean one of two things. One: it could mean that if a content creator sends a DMCA notice objecting to infringement of a work — let's say it's a texture — all copies of that texture should be removed from the grid and never be re-uploaded. Okay, so that would mean that anyone who bought the item would have it deleted from their inventory...when? At the moment of takedown notice? Do we give the other party time to counter-notice? How great would that be as an anti-competitive, griefing measure, if I could take my biggest competitor out by forcing LL to delete all their content, including content people had already legitimately bought, and never let them re-upload it?

Okay, maybe it wouldn't be that extreme. Maybe it would only mean that it couldn't be re-uploaded by that specific person, but it wouldn't be deleted from anyone's inventory. It'd still be a hell of a griefing tool, and that completely removes one of the DMCA's biggest benefits: the potential for the infringing side to /get permission/ from the rights holder, and then continue to use the work. The reason each side is given contact information for the other is so you have a chance to work out your differences and potentially license the work in question.

Finally, as much as /I/ would really like a system like the one Winter Seale proposes, it would only work as a voluntary, user-supported system. Linden Lab has to use the DMCA process as the law has established it, because that process (among some other stuff) gives Linden Lab immunity from copyright lawsuits. That process is a shield. When the law gives you a shield, you don't go messing with it, even if the shield doesn't work all that well for your business purposes. That's why you'll see the exact same basic process at any other user-generated content publishing site, like YouTube, Wordpress, Tumblr, or wherever.

Sorry. This was long. I did promise I'd comment, though.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.


Post a comment

Your Information

(Name is required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)

Making a Metaverse That Matters Wagner James Au ad
Please buy my book!
Thumb Wagner James Au Metaverse book
Wagner James "Hamlet" Au
Valentine Dutchie Second Life gift
Bad-Unicorn Funny Second Life items
Juicybomb_EEP ad
My book on Goodreads!
Wagner James Au AAE Speakers Metaverse
Request me as a speaker!
Making of Second Life 20th anniversary Wagner James Au Thumb
my site ... ... ...
PC for SL
Recommended PC for SL
Macbook Second Life
Recommended Mac for SL

Classic New World Notes stories:

Woman With Parkinson's Reports Significant Physical Recovery After Using Second Life - Academics Researching (2013)

We're Not Ready For An Era Where People Prefer Virtual Experiences To Real Ones -- But That Era Seems To Be Here (2012)

Sander's Villa: The Man Who Gave His Father A Second Life (2011)

What Rebecca Learned By Being A Second Life Man (2010)

Charles Bristol's Metaverse Blues: 87 Year Old Bluesman Becomes Avatar-Based Musician In Second Life (2009)

Linden Limit Libertarianism: Metaverse community management illustrates the problems with laissez faire governance (2008)

The Husband That Eshi Made: Metaverse artist, grieving for her dead husband, recreates him as an avatar (2008)

Labor Union Protesters Converge On IBM's Metaverse Campus: Leaders Claim Success, 1850 Total Attendees (Including Giant Banana & Talking Triangle) (2007)

All About My Avatar: The story behind amazing strange avatars (2007)

Fighting the Front: When fascists open an HQ in Second Life, chaos and exploding pigs ensue (2007)

Copying a Controversy: Copyright concerns come to the Metaverse via... the CopyBot! (2006)

The Penguin & the Zookeeper: Just another unlikely friendship formed in The Metaverse (2006)

"—And He Rezzed a Crooked House—": Mathematician makes a tesseract in the Metaverse — watch the videos! (2006)

Guarding Darfur: Virtual super heroes rally to protect a real world activist site (2006)

The Skin You're In: How virtual world avatar options expose real world racism (2006)

Making Love: When virtual sex gets real (2005)

Watching the Detectives: How to honeytrap a cheater in the Metaverse (2005)

The Freeform Identity of Eboni Khan: First-hand account of the Black user experience in virtual worlds (2005)

Man on Man and Woman on Woman: Just another gender-bending avatar love story, with a twist (2005)

The Nine Souls of Wilde Cunningham: A collective of severely disabled people share the same avatar (2004)

Falling for Eddie: Two shy artists divided by an ocean literally create a new life for each other (2004)

War of the Jessie Wall: Battle over virtual borders -- and real war in Iraq (2003)

Home for the Homeless: Creating a virtual mansion despite the most challenging circumstances (2003)

Newstex_Author_Badge-Color 240px
JuicyBomb_NWN5 SL blog
Ava Delaney SL Blog